| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4L | 4M | 4H |
Length
- counts only if not withen time limit | | timing too long or too short | | | | |
Organization
- how well is your overall presentation organized? | - major issues with organization - no logical flow to presentation | - some problems with organization - presentation not very logical overall | - good organization without any major issues | - very well organized | - excellent organized, very logical flow
| - as level 4M but with some kind of creative and/or additional unique feature to further improve organization |
Delivery (see list of skills below) - demonstration of excellent presenter skills and preparedness - engagement with audience | - very poor skills - presenter seem very unprepared | - presenters seem somewhat unprepared -not demonstrating good presenter skills | - presenters prepared - good skills overall - presentation is engaging - presentation is interesting and has some creativity | - excellent presentation - excellent presenter skills - keeps attention with strong creativity, organization, enthusiasm
| - flawless presenter skills - excellent creativity, organization and enthusiasm
| - Steve Jobs like engagement - everyone fully engaged by presentation |
Content
- is content researched, written, and prepared well? | - numerous issues listed in level 2 - incomplete work | - content has a few issues where research is either incomplete or somehow incorrect - problems with written portion of presentation, incorrect spelling, grammar, etc. - content not meeting expectation in any other way | - content is researched and well written | content very well researched, presentor able to able to answer questions and | Presenter knows much more about topic then is included in presentation, able to answer practically any questions about content. | presenter has mastered all of the content about the subject, Encyclopedic knowledge of topic. Presenter can answer any questions about topic. |
Design
- is the presentation designed well, is it visually interesting - are images used to reinforce the message? - is text used effectively, in point form with titles? - are effects and transitions used effectively? | - very poorly designed presentation with little or not attention given to design | - design has some problems such as too much text, unreadable text, not enough attention given to use of graphics, etc. | - overall well designed presentation with effective use of text | - very well designed with excellent use of text - very well designed | - as 4L with creative design and attention to overall aesthetic | - beautiful graphic design and effects, very creative with a truly professional look and feel |